Fair Warning: You Just Might Fall In Love With Us, Too.

"Everything about CustomMade was amazing from start to finish! The care and dedication they had to getting my fiancee's ring juuuuust right was nothing short of wonderful."

- Justin W.

All Reviews

4.91/5
13,851 Reviews
12,937
714
107
49
44

Our Review Policy

Each of our reviews is from a customer who purchased one of our custom designed pieces of jewelry. We never alter reviews, and offer no incentives for submitting a review of your experience.

Filter

Kaelan's avatar

Kaelan

Kaelan's Engagement Ring

4/4/25

    Kaelan's Engagement Ring 1Kaelan's Engagement Ring 2Kaelan's Engagement Ring 3Kaelan's Engagement Ring 4Kaelan's Engagement Ring 5Kaelan's Engagement Ring 6
I can’t remember if I found this place on insta or just found them when I looked up engagement ring creation online, but I’m so glad I found this place. From day one they have been so very helpful and able to help me with all of my silly questions, and make me feel very confident with the creation. It was really helpful and didn’t feel like I was getting pressured in any way. I had that experience of being pressured when I visited a couple of jewelry shops looking for a ring. Lastly I just wanna mention how absolutely adorable the things that come with the engagement ring. The little kit is very appreciated and will definitely be helpful.
Timeliness
Quality
Communication
Shipping/Delivery
Professionalism
Value
Continue Reading

Caleb

Caleb's Class Ring

4/4/25

    Caleb's Class Ring 1Caleb's Class Ring 2Caleb's Class Ring 3Caleb's Class Ring 4Caleb's Class Ring 5
The team was really patient with my questions, concerns, ideas. Even went as far as sending a video of the ring when I had questions about the pictures. It turned out perfectly.
Timeliness
Quality
Communication
Shipping/Delivery
Professionalism
Value
Continue Reading

Noah

Rachel's Engagement Ring

4/4/25

    Rachel's Engagement Ring 1Rachel's Engagement Ring 2Rachel's Engagement Ring 3Rachel's Engagement Ring 4Rachel's Engagement Ring 5Rachel's Engagement Ring 6
I was a little skeptical about getting a custom made piece online, however, simply within the first few minutes of being on their site, and talking with the designers all worries were gone. They worked with me so well, have reasonable prices for insanely good results and a completely custom piece, and come with insane benefits! I absolutely LOVE the piece I got to design and would recommend to anyone who wants a 100% custom ring or jewelry, they will make it worth your while!
Timeliness
Quality
Communication
Shipping/Delivery
Professionalism
Value
Continue Reading

Robert

Robert's Signet Ring

4/4/25

    Robert's Signet Ring 1Robert's Signet Ring 2Robert's Signet Ring 3Robert's Signet Ring 4
Oh My God!

This ring is absolutely magnificent.

The “Escudo” of my family goes back close to 800 years.

The ring captures it perfectly.

You have created a family heirloom.

Thank you!

LTC (RET) Robert Clarke Fernandez De La Reguera.

USA
Timeliness
Quality
Communication
Shipping/Delivery
Professionalism
Value
Continue Reading
Justin's avatar

Justin

Justin's Wedding Band

4/3/25

    Justin's Wedding Band 1Justin's Wedding Band 2Justin's Wedding Band 3Justin's Wedding Band 4Justin's Wedding Band 5Justin's Wedding Band 6Justin's Wedding Band 7Justin's Wedding Band 8Justin's Wedding Band 9Justin's Wedding Band 10Justin's Wedding Band 11
Love what The Custome Made Team did for us again beautiful work wouldn’t go anywhere else
Timeliness
Quality
Communication
Shipping/Delivery
Professionalism
Value
Continue Reading
Ryon's avatar

Ryon

Stephanie's Bridal Set

4/3/25

    Stephanie's Bridal Set 1Stephanie's Bridal Set 2Stephanie's Bridal Set 3Stephanie's Bridal Set 4Stephanie's Bridal Set 5Stephanie's Bridal Set 6Stephanie's Bridal Set 7

Timeliness
Quality
Communication
Shipping/Delivery
Professionalism
Value
Continue Reading

Bianca

Bianca's Engagement Ring

4/3/25

    Bianca's Engagement Ring 1Bianca's Engagement Ring 2Bianca's Engagement Ring 3Bianca's Engagement Ring 4Bianca's Engagement Ring 5Bianca's Engagement Ring 6Bianca's Engagement Ring 7
Sama was great with communicating my design preferences and the stages of production of my ring. The design team did a phenomenal job on my ring. The quality, stone, and engraving were top notch and I would recommend Custom Made to anyone looking for an engagement ring.
Timeliness
Quality
Communication
Shipping/Delivery
Professionalism
Value
Continue Reading

Eli

Angel's Engagement Ring

4/3/25

    Angel's Engagement Ring 1Angel's Engagement Ring 2Angel's Engagement Ring 3Angel's Engagement Ring 4Angel's Engagement Ring 5Angel's Engagement Ring 6
Very smooth, very informative, would recommend to anyone who is looking!
Timeliness
Quality
Communication
Shipping/Delivery
Professionalism
Value
Continue Reading

Connor

Savannah's Engagement Ring

4/3/25

    Savannah's Engagement Ring 1Savannah's Engagement Ring 2Savannah's Engagement Ring 3Savannah's Engagement Ring 4Savannah's Engagement Ring 5Savannah's Engagement Ring 6

Timeliness
Quality
Communication
Shipping/Delivery
Professionalism
Value
Continue Reading

Eyal

Eyal's Necklace

4/2/25

    Eyal's Necklace 1Eyal's Necklace 2Eyal's Necklace 3
Very helpful team for a clueless customer like me

They were great. I've never bought jewelry for my wife before but I took a photo of something that I found on TV and they walked me through the process. They were patient as I was going back and forth between design options. They also helped me make decisions that I wasn't sure about like which type of gold, how long a chain, etc. They were also very responsive, writing me back within a day or even just hours. In the end, I paid and got the necklace. It was all straightforward, even for an amateur like me!
Timeliness
Quality
Communication
Shipping/Delivery
Professionalism
Value
Continue Reading
5-point gold star 5-point grey star